Who Did and Didn't Sing Live: MBC 2020 

مشترک شدن
بازدید 55K
97% 539 12

Today, we’re very apprehensively reviewing MBC’s Music Festival because SBS blocked my last video world wide. I should have known because this isn’t the first time SBS did that to me, but I forgot for whatever reason. But I digress! Today I’m going to share with you my thoughts on the performances as seen on MBC’s Music Festival/Gayo Daejejeon, from who I think is singing live to who is lip syncing and honestly not too much in between because MBC came through with the live vocals and I think this is the best award show I’ve seen so far.
On to my disclaimer: if an idol choses to lip sync, that’s fine. MBC uploaded this to youtube for free, it would be ideal to hear live vocals and I appreciate that, but idols and companies can have their reasons for not wanting to. Whether it’s to avoid scandals or to just achieve a more perfect sound, since some people think LMR, live vocals with a back up track can sound messy. But honestly not many groups did lip sync on MBC, so I’m really excited to get into this video.
become a COCKA2 by subscribing to my channel 'angelina' & hit the bell for more kpop shenanigans » bit.ly/2Boj1bW
INSTAGRAM » moluccensis
2ND CHANNEL » iritem.info
BUSINESS » moluccensis@aol.com
COKODIVE Kpop Albums | Use Code “ANGELINA” FOR 10% Off!*
ExpressVPN | Get 3 Months FREE!*
YESSTYLE | Use Code “PARROT10” FOR 10% Off!*
*disclosure: the links above are affiliate links, meaning that I will earn commission if you click through and make a purchase!
OUTRO » vhs - montreal
0:00 Intro
0:53 Types of Performances
2:32 Special Stages
5:12 Twice
7:43 Oh My Girl
8:10 Got7
8:42 The Boyz
9:38 Itzy
10:28 Jessi
10:59 Hwasa + Mamamoo
12:03 Stray kids, Monsta X
12:34 Loona
13:08 (G)i-dle
13:51 IZ*ONE
14:40 Aespa
15:57 NCT

[ angelina ]


تاریخ انتشار


2021 5 ژانویه





افزودن به:

لیست پخش من
تماشا در فرصتی دیگر
نظر 100   
Shadi Alaha
Shadi Alaha پیش 7 ساعت
sbs blocked u cuz ur dumb
Shadi Alaha
Shadi Alaha پیش 7 ساعت
poor girl....
MARIa Yanez
MARIa Yanez پیش 5 روز
Keep twice out of your mouth. It’s so obvious u don’t like em. Now go on with ur faves and forget about twice.
Guilherme Kawakami
Guilherme Kawakami پیش 8 روز
I'm quite sad IZ*ONE did LAR. They are so stable.
VoteForTwiceOn-H1 SMA-GDA-andGlobalFansChoiceAward
U know, why I don't hate Twice because of lip-syncing? 1. I watched Sixteen. 2. I watched, how they improved. 3. I also saw the BAD half-breath & half-voice technique. 4. I saw them being overworked and being criticized for vocal mistakes miserably. 5. I also saw, how the BAD technique affected them. 6. I saw, Jihyo's Jazzy voice was never utilized. 7. I also saw Nayeon's high notes being pitchy. 8. I noticed that only a few groups had a great range of vocal timbres. 9. I saw, Twice's performances had the largest number of MR removed. 10. If u watched their Sixteen era, concerts and covers especially early ones, U will agree with me. At last, I want to say that I love SM for their best vocal coaches and training.
Naviana پیش 9 روز
i actually prefer their live vocals because it shows their real talent compared to lip syncing, even if the live vocals sound a bit messy
Margaretha Selvia
Margaretha Selvia پیش 13 روز
A-M2 پیش 14 روز
I feel so dumb asking this (I've been a kpop fan since 2006) but what is LAR VS LMR?? 😭
gigicmaoj deobi
gigicmaoj deobi پیش 16 روز
I want those live vocals. I don't care about whether they make mistakes. I have the same pet peeve with NCT. I mean SM grooms their idols to have some of the best vocals in the industry but they rarely use them on award shows. And as a huge fan of The Boyz, I cherish every time they give us live vocal performances.
Seen _
Seen _ پیش 16 روز
the fact she literally wears the same black jumper every video proves she has dedication
Foxy_Kpop_ LS
Foxy_Kpop_ LS پیش 16 روز
Live its reallg nice to see that they have confidence to sing live even if they have a voice crack
Reece Graham
Reece Graham پیش 17 روز
Tbh i dont think we can ever expect NCT to perform Resonance live since that song is basically a remix/medley of a bunch of their releases that was made purely for dance performances. And idk SM this year esp seems pretty hell bent on making their younger groups to only stick to the choreo. Which is a shame cause I *know* for a fact that they are capable of live singing 😔
Myka Estavas
Myka Estavas پیش 17 روز
It's kinda sad because they bash groups for lip syncing, but when they sing live they call them out for their mistakes. Like what did you expect?
Sems Classic
Sems Classic پیش 17 روز
Honestly I dislike live vocals simply because the backtracks are always so loud and the dissonance between the super smooth vocals and the rawer ones sounds god-awful. I would rather have performances with pre-recorded live vocals and full out dancing or fully live performances with very minimalistic dances, because looking at some of those, I'm neither enjoying the vocals or the dancing. I was bothered about what felt so wrong watching this award show and I think that basically boils down to that - with, additionally, a clear lack of audience-induced energy. Standing on a stage with hundreds, thousands of people singing and screaming alongside you gives you so much adrenaline that I personally find quite lacking with a lot of this year's awards show performances - but it's also important to remember some of these groups are either in the middle of preparing their next comebacks or finishing up promotions, or have been straight up overworked in the middle of a pandemic this last year. Even if Korea hasn't been hit as hard as a lot of countries, we're still living through deeply traumatic times and that's not even starting on foreign idols whose families might be in greater danger than they are. Anyway, thank you Angelina for the great content as always !
Hirumi Yamada
Hirumi Yamada پیش 17 روز
Itzy gave us what we want. Live singing & new choreos.
Prapti پیش 17 روز
My faves were loona and The boyz` stage~
Nana Rii
Nana Rii پیش 17 روز
Jyp artist sing live vocal the most nowadays, also yg artist did sing live, I dont know about treasure but ikon and blackpink are good at live performance
Nikki Esmeralda
Nikki Esmeralda پیش 17 روز
Itzy always has one the hardest dance choreo for a girl group, but they still always try to sing live! 👏🏽 👏🏽 👏🏽
정유비 پیش 17 روز
Stan the boyz
AARON ADONA پیش 18 روز
MBC remove the first video of izone which is not lipsync and MBC re upload the video which is lypsync and edited so MBC waste the 1M views of live panorama :< Sorry for my English, im fluent in English
Maarvin پیش 18 روز
Good vocal >> Good dance
Digggyyyyy پیش 18 روز
Personally I love real, raw vocals in a performance and would be more than happy either for vocals to have plenty of imperfections or to have less intense choreography to help with vocals. To me a live performance without live vocals is no longer a live performance and I might as well just watch a dance practice or dance cover. K-pop idols are, to me, singers first and foremost. Without live vocals performances feel hollow and I feel nothing from them, whereas I get genuinely excited when groups sing live and do a good job - I just watched STAYC cover Way to Go and I was ecstatic throughout to see a real performance with imperfections, clear effort in the vocals and genuinely great live singing! A good live performance always makes me more proud of my groups than most other things.
Weii Chan
Weii Chan پیش 18 روز
Actually there are a lot of performances when bangchan stray kids harmonising with his own voice back track and he did it beautifully! ^^
GeeCee پیش 18 روز
Mamamoo never disappointing with their vocals. Ears blessed.
Meliodas96 پیش 18 روز
Why are u so obsessed with singing and not singing live
Sarah Piccoli
Sarah Piccoli پیش 18 روز
I love how you use comparison clips in order to really show us what you mean. Super interesting!
Aito Nguyen
Aito Nguyen پیش 19 روز
I want idols to sing live more, we learn from our mistakes and improve it. Mistakes are ok to make.
Hey nct
Hey nct پیش 19 روز
iwish nct would sing live more often because they have so many really good vocalists
Lima Bean
Lima Bean پیش 19 روز
I heard a stage/music technician say that they can only have 5 mics on at a time for live signing performances. Wonder if this is true and if so then all the other members of bands with more than 5 members must be miming. (That is if anyone is actually signing live).
Leonor Falcão
Leonor Falcão پیش 19 روز
angelina!!!! VERY IMPORTANT go watch STAYC new stage covering WAY TO GO
deHuntr پیش 19 روز
When the choreography is too intense and has so many hardcore movements, I mean yeah I get it and it's understandable situation if idols did lip-sync or having loud playback on purpose to hide their live vocals. BUT if they're just only standing there with small and easy movement but still doing lip-sync, it just looks ridiculous and they should actually sing live (or at least with very minimal/lower playback).
Hernandez, Lance Simoun P.
as expected in itzy
tomato پیش 19 روز
or maybe dj xiao is really that good of a vocalist 🤔 🤨 🧐
mariannette پیش 19 روز
first of all, you're so pretty~ I'm not even sure why i'm here haha. I already know Mamamoo always sing live and their vocals are always amazing. Very strong individually and as a group too. I'm not really into super intense choreography - don't know how people can point out tiny mistakes in the dance like that. What's important to me is the overall presence of the group/the energy(?), how they can hype up a crowd. I just wanna see groups actually look like they enjoy what they're doing on stage~ unfortunately some fans are so nitpicky(?).
tomato پیش 19 روز
tbh got7 aint ever scared fo sing live lol
Why is it not SEOJUN?
Why is it not SEOJUN? پیش 19 روز
Itzy Sings live in most stages.
itzypinks پیش 19 روز
i like hearing idols sing live and all the little imperfections in their voices, it makes them feel more like real people rather than singing robots
SilverWaterlily پیش 19 روز
One of the things that peeves me so muchis when you find one of those rare performances where at least one of the idols sings live and people are all like. "They must be sick/ tired. " No fool! That's what real vocals sound like. Perfect vocals are not real. Even the best singers in the industry don't sound exactly like studio versions.
Blankk پیش 19 روز
Sameee, i only like blackpink from yg and i like itzy and twice from jyp. Lmao
Audrey Hermanto
Audrey Hermanto پیش 19 روز
Can anyone tell me when the voting for AKMA happened cause I didn't see the link
Chewy Chu
Chewy Chu پیش 19 روز
Am i the only one who doesn't think Jihyo made a mistake? I mean i thought that was actually part of the dance since it was a disco ver and the move is kinda disco-ish.
frappi پیش 19 روز
My favorite part about the stealer performances (not just this one) is when changmin lands from jumping off the other member’s back and goes straight into singing, you can hear him stabilizing his breathing hes SO talented!
Maurice Johnson
Maurice Johnson پیش 19 روز
momochi پیش 19 روز
honestly, i do not mind idols lip syncing. i think it’s better overall for them so that they can give an amazing performance and focus on their facials and dancing. i think it’s great that idols have chances to sing live, but i think if they are going to sing live, they should be completely live. i personally do not like hearing two voices, it really bothers me.
ICSM Daily Views
ICSM Daily Views پیش 19 روز
Hi Sister Angelina i really love watching your video you are so relaxing
lovesick boy
lovesick boy پیش 19 روز
U taurus
Lylias پیش 19 روز
I SOOOO prefer hearing them live. I came quite late to the kpop scene (2017) as I'm super late to comment on this video lol and thanks to your videos I learned about the difference in live vocals between generations and like... I don't get how we got here. I need to speak to the manager. I completely understand it's just impossible for idols to do those choreos and sing at the same time, and that's ok. But I have to be honest with myself and admit that on the back of my mind, when I can NEVER get live vocals from a group I... just cant seem to be able to engage with them? Many of my favorite groups have gotten there because of their live performances, the acting, the energy, the vocals... I just get SO drawn in to them like I'm being hypnotized xD
Ami A
Ami A پیش 19 روز
2021 and I’m still waiting for Aespa to sing live
Ami A
Ami A پیش 19 روز
Oh my girl had the most live vocals
Hangyul Yi
Hangyul Yi پیش 19 روز
dunno if you saw the cue sheet(?) for this but the special stages, (at least the ones in the beginning) are all LAR and aespa, stray kids, and loona are stated as MR
Ami A
Ami A پیش 19 روز
@Hangyul Yi Oh my bad, I misread and made a mistake. So yeah MR is live. For some reason I was thinking of AR and LAR.
Hangyul Yi
Hangyul Yi پیش 19 روز
@Ami A why would they be differentiated then if they're the same?
Ami A
Ami A پیش 19 روز
LAR and MR it still all lipsynced.
mochi پیش 19 روز
angelina i know your seeing this heart me lmao
weewoo wee
weewoo wee پیش 20 روز
it’s not easy to sing live especially high notes while dancing but atleast they recorded it with their own voices
Chandrima Some BOTA 22
Chandrima Some BOTA 22 پیش 20 روز
Stan The Boyz for clear skin!!!!
Talya Simchi
Talya Simchi پیش 20 روز
Gidle did sing live in this performance but the backuptrack was very loud
Hey Jamnyam
Hey Jamnyam پیش 20 روز
Even if they live singing, the show will edit their voice:') like come on! They can sing and let them show their voice😭
zoe leigh
zoe leigh پیش 20 روز
how you explained wanting to hear what you're seeing in regards to live vocals is like the perfect way to describe it tbh. i love hearing live vocals and i wish that the definition of perfection in kpop changed from literally being beyond the limits of humans and to giving it your all and putting on a performance.
Yxmazaki 44
Yxmazaki 44 پیش 20 روز
The Boyz dances are super hard because they're more performance based sometimes, but when they get to sing live they show how greatly they can do it. They're super talented and I think all groups have their own things. Like you can prefer vocals but hard dances doesn't mean they're not vocally talented and yeah... I don't think any groups, disregarding of the choreos, do that much live this days... that's annoying but that's a lot of people decision and I don't think they have that much to say about that. And like she said : that's not a bad thing to not sing live but people do be using this and hard choreo to drag idols and that's why some people are pretty defensive about that, but that doesn't change anything
PhotographicEvidence پیش 20 روز
this is the first time Loona got invited to year-end show im so happy for them
jjjulia127 پیش 20 روز
No comments abt HwaSa and MAMAMOO. OK! They are just Queens of live vocal)
guitarchris76 پیش 20 روز
This was such a great video. It is awesome to hear live singing. I've always loved Twice but have been very disappointed in their live vocals. Their live vocals here sound amazing. Love the trend and love the vid.
NicoolMR پیش 20 روز
Monsta X♥️
Jana Grafeneder
Jana Grafeneder پیش 20 روز
I loooved The Boyz and LOONA‘s stage!!!
kimchirice پیش 20 روز
i am nctzen and i could tell that they performed with the actual studio music (except for jeno's part)
Aisyah Fitri Azalia
Aisyah Fitri Azalia پیش 20 روز
Just when the hell this LAR era started? Nowadays the choreographies are getting harder and harder and live singing are getting rare
Ami A
Ami A پیش 19 روز
Started near the end of 3rd gen
Urie Kuki
Urie Kuki پیش 20 روز
no loona?
GAE FOR IRENE BAE پیش 20 روز
Here cause the boyz new in thumbnail cause we don't get that alot. 😍 Edit: thank you for the honest appreciation of the boyz, cause people don't talk about the standards their serving enough queen😘
Meienais پیش 20 روز
Angelina will you do an ranking/roasting i can't stop me oufits? can't wait to see it if you're preparing one^^
Kp1390 پیش 20 روز
I hate the backup track it sounds like a echo. Rather hear live vocals. People that want things perfect should just stick to the mv and never go to a live recording and concert. They are putting a lot of effort into their vocals but it's being drawn out because some people are stupid and they want perfection.
Mishary Aldamjani
Mishary Aldamjani پیش 20 روز
angelina the dislike's is from mbc and sbs ok
Got7 Visual
Got7 Visual پیش 20 روز
When you all cant accept that your fave lip syn.....hahaha....sorry but i prefer live
Michaela Kunešová
Michaela Kunešová پیش 20 روز
I hate how they autotune everything. Just like you said - no emotion and tbh it's boring. I love the little inconsistencies and imperfections, it makes every performance special. I still like music more and i'd be happier if idols tuned down on the choreography and sang live more. And ofc if the music shows stopped the obsession with perfect vocals.
By Rere
By Rere پیش 20 روز
Can you please talk about the new year shows? Sm and bighit? Very curious for your thoughts
Nanda M
Nanda M پیش 20 روز
I like both seeing the choreography and live singing. It just doesn't have to be at the same time you know? That's why I like sm's system of lip syncing the first week on music shows when they comeback. For the first week you can enjoy the whole choreo and for the rest of the promotions the artists focus on live singing. I remember Tiffany's debut with IJWD and I love it the choreo at the ground, which she did at the first week when she was lip syncing and then when she sang live she didn't do the choreo anymore but people were hating on her bcs they wanted her to sing live AND do the choreo perfectly which I tought was really rude.
Rv On Orbit
Rv On Orbit پیش 20 روز
one of the most annyoing sht is how some grp's recent releases have less difficult choreographies to be able to sing them live but they still don't let them
Rv On Orbit
Rv On Orbit پیش 20 روز
it's sad how kpop is becoming more and more popular in the western but less and less in south korea yet they still have these korean visual-more-than-anything-performences requests. LET THE PEOPLE SING!
Ivanna Turangan
Ivanna Turangan پیش 20 روز
Let's agree Mamamoo never disappoint when it comes to vocals :)
lucy seaflyer
lucy seaflyer پیش 20 روز
I thought the point of getting a music video, performance video, dance practice video, relay dance video, stages videos, etc, was to appreciate the choreography so then at award shows & other live events they could adjust the choreo to prioritize vocals. Maybe I’m old (and not necessarily 2nd gen but even in western shows live vocals are rare now) and I miss how much more heartfelt that singing felt.
Ami A
Ami A پیش 19 روز
This how I thought it was meant to be
Rajpal Bhatia
Rajpal Bhatia پیش 20 روز
i kinda have started liking you dude
Ari :3
Ari :3 پیش 20 روز
As someone who is a vocalist and dancer, I’ve tried dancing and singing and it’s really hard. These idols are very talented even if they’re just lip syncing, Singing while dancing is hard
Jevid Labasan
Jevid Labasan پیش 20 روز
Id prefer theyll perfect the choreo rather than the live vocals, it's all about time for the dancers to showcase their talents. *** Songs (Vocals) - to Hear Dances - to See (Visual) *** We can listen to songs to their vocals everytime but we can't watch dance practices all the time. *Also we have radios (sadly not available for international fans unless there's a way you can) that they can focus for Live Vocals. Also, mostly dancers just have fewer line in the songs we listen to as they focused to dancing obviously, so we can only see their dances through dance practice, some clips in their MVs and oc Live Performances. But they're idols, they sing and dance at the same time, but also they can do what they want. Honestly, it's still okay to perform live, to lipsync, to have a mistake, to dance lazy. KPop idols are one of the most hardworking people right now, so we should always appreciate them.
Rajpal Bhatia
Rajpal Bhatia پیش 20 روز
Twice performs in every possible year end show they can
Ami A
Ami A پیش 19 روز
Lmfao they have no choice
Sincerely Defiant
Sincerely Defiant پیش 20 روز
Live vocals any day.
Sincerely Defiant
Sincerely Defiant پیش 20 روز
Sadly I don't think I've heard izone sing live much if at all.
maria acuna
maria acuna پیش 20 روز
Choi Chanhee in the thumbnail is just chef kiss
Sincerely Defiant
Sincerely Defiant پیش 20 روز
This is why jpop handles vocals way better. The singing member is usually standing still or doing very light choreo. I really hope that happens in K-pop but it's just a dream. Sadly, jpop is now in fact emulating K-pop more and more.
Sincerely Defiant
Sincerely Defiant پیش 20 روز
I love that idols slow down to actually sing. I prefer that over slip syncing
Sincerely Defiant
Sincerely Defiant پیش 20 روز
You hear double vocals, there's a chance the lower volume voice is the idol actually singing.
Aebbeh پیش 20 روز
I'ma be honest, Loona are my girlies but, The Boyz x Loona was a weird cover because there were people who were doing like dance adlibs that usually would indicate lipsynching? But they weren't so it was just a random person doing something different for some reason??
gbralenaa پیش 20 روز
my favorite dance cover from mbc 2020 definitely is loona x the boyz covering blinding lights because the choreo, the visuals and the oufits were perfect, although every cover was good and every idol did really great🐸
alizlovescherry پیش 21 روز
Finally, I decide to support you! Thank you for keeping me up with the KPop news ❤️
The CC
The CC پیش 21 روز
Sad thing is that even if the idols do actually sing live and make a mistake, people will start bashing them. I really wish live vocals are more normalised in kpop.
marcela gimenez
marcela gimenez پیش 21 روز
I would pay to have those 2nd gen live vocals back, but unfortunately, this is just the way fans consume kpop nowadays 😥 super sad actually..... NCT has the best vocals in the industry and we only have LAR performances!!!
AHNUC پیش 21 روز
Sulistia Fahrunnisa Imani
Sulistia Fahrunnisa Imani پیش 21 روز
I've watch live izone concert on 2019. And yeah, some of the members singing live and the rest do lip syncing. Seems like the agc make a back track where some members recorded their voice as pre-recorded sound, and the rest aren't do that. in this mbc performance, they still use the pre-recorded sounds pretty loud but members like yujin, nako, hitomi sang their whole part pretty loud and i can say it's stable enough for this high pitch song with hard choreo, you can hear it on asmr audio. for minjoo, yuri, chaewon, yena, chaeyeon. they sang some of their part, eventho it sound of of breath and a little messy but i appreciated they're trying to sing. it's better to sounds messy or out of breath cuz you can improve for a better perfomance and know where part you didn't have to sing because of part still easy to singing while dancing. i really am appreciated. and next for eunbi i feel like she didn't sing at all but at the second chorus when she almost finish her part she sang her part eventho it sound so breathy almost no voice. but i understand that since all of her part are high pitched. cuz i'm sure she can do better and singing really well next time. same goes with hyewon and sakura, they do the same thing like eunbi but they're actually singing but it sound so airy and we almost didn't hear that, but these two singing their part. and last wonyoung.... i can say she didn't sing at all, like the whole her part. you can she's so smiley through the perfomance especially for her first part "chajaon jageun gieok", it's really imposibble singing that part with that kind of her lips moves. well i can see their own prioritize like wonyoung > stage presence eunbi, sakura, hyewon > the choreograpy and stage presence and the rest especially Yujin, Nako and Hitomi really did a great job with that powerful stage presence, the choreo and they still manage to singing. Ugh i love them all so much.
R پیش 21 روز
ITZY singing live VOCALS, they'd know how to control their voices while dancing.. it's literally called technique.
eina ANNA
eina ANNA پیش 21 روز
I defo prefer life vocals. I remember that itzy once did a dance practice video where they sang live and that was amazing!!!!!
oscar پیش 21 روز
Idk how to say this? But i feel like if sm’s vocals aren’t put on such a pedestal, Aespa would probably get to sing live more. Like when they just debuted people were like “ Winter can totally be a main vocal in another group” or “Ningning is the best main vocal in the 4th gen”. And they also had to live up to the legacy of their sunbaes, Like GG, F(x) and RV so i think sm played it safe and let them lip sync instead. In conclusion, if ppl treated them like humans who will definitely sing slightly off doing that kind of choreo, instead of “sm idols who never make a vocal mistake”, then they’d definitely be able to sing live more.
Kpop Studios
Kpop Studios پیش 21 روز
I love my live vocals 👹
Happiness Delight
Happiness Delight پیش 21 روز
Live vocals for me.
akaira's dream
akaira's dream پیش 21 روز
I wish if DREAMCATCHER were invited in a single award show because they definitely can sing and be stable in a live performance. Just sayinn
بازدید 2.6M
بازدید 2.6M
How Arby’s delivery be
بازدید 758K