Let's Talk About Treasure's Debut with "BOY" 

مشترک شدن
بازدید 84K
86% 727 117

TREASURE - 'BOY' M/V » iritem.info/cd/fy-lm-h-y/gLZylrbNl3KXank.html
Is Treasure's Debut with "BOY" a Flop? Are they flopping hardcore compared to their seniors, Ikon, Winner and Blackpink in the charts? Do they lack that YG vibe?
So treasure just made their debut with their title track “boy” and it seems there’s a lot of discussion surrounding it. I thought it would be interesting to have this discussion, because I’m seeing a lot of people saying that their debut is a flop, that this isn’t a unique YG sound and that this is not what people were expecting.
While on the other hand, it seems like Treasure is thriving so I’m a bit confused. So I think it’s time for an episode of Kpop investigations, where I basically take a subject and do a little bit of a deep dive into it. So let’s talk about Treasure’s debut.
become a COCKA2 by subscribing to my channel 'angelina' & hit the bell for more kpop shenanigans » bit.ly/2Boj1bW

INSTAGRAM » moluccensis
2ND CHANNEL » iritem.info
BUSINESS » minjivanpark@gmail.com
✨MAGICAL KPOP on Spotify✨
OUTRO » vhs - montreal
TREASURE Surpasses 150,000 Stock Pre-Orders » bit.ly/33S6I3V
BIGBANG - FOREVER WITH U M/V » iritem.info/cd/fy-lm-h-y/fbx0dJiwu3OYjIU.html
보이프렌드(BOYFRIEND) - Boyfriend Music Video » iritem.info/cd/fy-lm-h-y/sMdmd63bvYjTr4k.html
iKON - 취향저격(MY TYPE) M/V » iritem.info/cd/fy-lm-h-y/kLZnpszbmqTYr5s.html
[ angelina ]

راهنماها و مد

تاریخ انتشار


2020 8 اوت





افزودن به:

لیست پخش من
تماشا در فرصتی دیگر
نظر 100   
angelina پیش 5 ماه
🌸💕🐠FOLLOW ME🌈🦋🦄 IG » instagram.com/moluccensis SPOTIFY » spoti.fi/2DNhgGa
n김 치소
n김 치소 پیش 24 روز
They floppp
ju lie
ju lie پیش 5 ماه
n unsa k oi.... pag stan s imong group n gusto ayaw patakag yawit dra...🤪
Fishy The Fish
Fishy The Fish پیش 5 ماه
"with friends you don't have" whyd you expose me like that-
Score 4371
Score 4371 پیش 5 ماه
Valerie green that’s pretty funny cuz most of you kpop fans do the exact opposite and I’m a kpop fan myself...a bunch of you talk like you won’t get mad when someone goes against your opinion but do the exact opposite...
Deep Luna
Deep Luna پیش 5 ماه
@Haru To same goes for Blackpink , she keeps on comparing Blackpink to 2ne1 and now Treasure with their seniors lol she is heck of a attention seeker lol , she just wants clout guys don't give her any I already unsubscribed her 🤡
Melita Banting
Melita Banting پیش 7 دقیقه
it just not your taste lol
Nutty 02
Nutty 02 پیش 2 روز
As a YG stan, i dont really favour when YGA are described as “yg vibes”. Each artist (i mean Artist!) have their own style and sound (ie AKMU, BP, Ikon,winner). YGA are known to have unique vocals and rappers since the start. That alr explains how different they are. When it comes to treasure, i personally dont feel any “yg vibes” when i first heard boy except for the ending. Its really a new sound & concept from yg. And i truly loved it. They are just starting to find & explore their sound. The members also have interest in producing and writing songs since their predebut days (the songs are awesome too) Good Things take time & i am sure they have more to offer. After the achievements they made as a rookie, its not right to claim them as “flop”. They went through ALOT to get here. With what happened to yg in 2019, additional burdens were added. Despite that, they did well for their debut. It may not be a song which suits all preferences, but you cannot deny how they rock their live performances :)
pjwolf پیش 12 روز
I stan Treasure one week after they debuted. I left my ult group that I stan 4 years. And I think that is scary. It is not just me who experience this. Let's give time.
マイク پیش 18 روز
As for me personally, I cringe every time idols debut with any love song. Come on, most of them are barely 18 and they got into training when they were 15 if not less. After all, they don't just sing about love, they sing and dance to cheesy songs... I'm like 😶😰🤢🤢🤢🤢 every time it happens :\\\\\\\\
glxry dayss
glxry dayss پیش 19 روز
Yeah stfu
Someone would said " I regret judging Treasure for saying FLOP." Actually they did great and slowly getting up there.
Ashuri Yamamoto
Ashuri Yamamoto پیش ماه
so who's flopping on charts now? Lmao they're higher that newly debuted groups now ksksksks
Tabitha Parks
Tabitha Parks پیش روز
Let's talk about physical and Gaon and Melon.
Tabitha Parks
Tabitha Parks پیش روز
Dude who TF you referring to?
S Monte
S Monte پیش ماه
People forgetting what happened last year to YG?! Fix your brains.
yoshi stan
yoshi stan پیش ماه
you know who's a flop angelina? YOU :>
The Water's Gray
The Water's Gray پیش ماه
People commenting from "they have the same YG formula" to "it does not have the same YG vibes" is just sickening AF. I ENJOYED AND LOVE THEIR SONG(S). Hence saying "should be blah blah" is irrelevant because People Have Opinions and Tastes. Plus do people even educate themselves with basic info such as their ages implying their concepts(for now) ?
chilli پیش ماه
it didnt give yg vibes??? do u even know what is yg? lol its been 3 months look at them now half million seller period
Ni-ki پیش ماه
Nobody: Me: Angelina showing off her blackpink light stick
Xy Skylar
Xy Skylar پیش ماه
Why do bgs generally do bad with charts like Melon (except BTS)? If they can sold 300k to more than 1 million physical albums easily, can't those 300k to 1 million people also listen to the music on these platforms? Kpop fandoms are very competitive so I find this really weird. And YG groups are known to be good with digitals, so I don't know what happened to this group.
glxry dayss
glxry dayss پیش 19 روز
The scandals sweetie
sugoi jen
sugoi jen پیش ماه
literally if you were into Kpop you would know YG had been going downhill since early 2019 because of the scandals. I also heard that knetz are boycotting groups that YG is going to debut. obv except for the groups that already debuted like blackpink, iKON, winner, akmu. and kinda weird since all of treasure songs topped music charts outside of Korea. Like line music in Japan. they had three songs in top 1 for weeks.
Aysah GD
Aysah GD پیش 2 ماه
For those who said Treasure was a Flop, don't judge the book by it's cover. Wait for them. This is just their beginnings.
Antonette Anrikamae Rodrigo
I read that Treasure getting into those kcharts 3 hours after their debut is already a flex because not all rookies can even probably enter those charts at that rate.
junkyutiee پیش 2 ماه
Lmaooo people are calling treasure flops and now just after 3 months of their debut they sold 700k+ albums.this proves that treasure aren’t flops ⚡️
glxry dayss
glxry dayss پیش 19 روز
@Mimi Rara darling you look like an idiot
junkyutiee پیش 2 ماه
@Daisy Loves Daisies YASS SAY IT LOUDER
Daisy Loves Daisies
Daisy Loves Daisies پیش 2 ماه
Mimi Rara Then go watch Tmap and u'll feel the difference from other boy groups Sweetie!
Mimi Rara
Mimi Rara پیش 2 ماه
They still flopped in Korea and digital, chart. The hype they gotten esp from southeast asian fans are overhyped. Plus their songs really dont have any difference with other rookie bg. Same formula. Album tracks are nah. Nothing special, no one stand out much except Yedam +My harsh opinion, but this is rly what I felt and yes I watch treasure box
Danh Nguyen
Danh Nguyen پیش 2 ماه
I’m this close to unstanning. Same EDM drop choruses for each song and doesn’t even change their concepts. “Your disrespecting a not even 1 month group”, it’s been 3 months already and I still haven’t changed my mind. For I was VERY excited, literally shaking like crazy. For I was pretty excited. But for , I wasn’t even excited at all. And that’s why I always like their b-sides more cause it’s different and concept is different. Yes, some kpop fans are right about boy groups being “repetitive” with their title tracks and that they don’t stand out. One of of the reasons I wasn’t excited for this comeback was because I was scared for there health. LITERALLY EACH MONTH they have a comeback. Imagine how tiring it was for them to practice hours when they have a schedules literally everyday. An example for not having “repetitive” comebacks is BTS. Look at , look at , look at . They did a successful job at the charts, wins, and views because the concept was different and not “repetitive”. And no, im not hating on the company, there producers, and DEFINITELY not the members. It’s not their music is getting “repetitive” and it’s starting to get boring FOR ME. If they don’t change their concept next comeback, I may have to unstan. I’m sry.
Reed Magusara
Reed Magusara پیش 3 ماه
Maybe you think they dont like YG sounds will your wrong hahaha its totally YG sound or vibe maybe their concept is teen crush but its totally yg vibe maybe for now they dont do baddass concept but if yoy teumes youll wait and see maybe in the future they will show what they got
Godwin Ekeh
Godwin Ekeh پیش 3 ماه
Honestly it wasn’t it a flop it was a solid debut for me I just don’t like it because when your debuting your supposed to showcase your talent really make a mark and distinct your selves from other groups and really show them what your made of it really didn’t for me not saying that there not talented because they are but I’m not hater cause I do stan blackpink and ikon so I feel if they focused more on the overall song it could have been better instead of the mv but some people like it that’s there opinion but I just think it doesn’t really compete with some rookies that debuted this year how are they supposed to compete with big groups like txt,cravity,mcnd,too,dkb,elast groups that really showed their own unique and distinctive sound. Overall okay debut it kinda just went over my head
Maheswarry Jasheena
Maheswarry Jasheena پیش 4 ماه
bodo amat anjing
PRince YOSHI پیش 4 ماه
treasure is no 1 of the most pre order debut album 170000 copies in 24 hours.😄
punTEEZ پیش 4 ماه
There's just that one group that raised the standard that I can't find bg these days that appealing.
punTEEZ پیش 4 ماه
There's just that one group that raised the standard that I can't find bg these days that appealing.
Jaeminti :3
Jaeminti :3 پیش 4 ماه
My problem is it sounds amazing and their dancing is amazing BUT the chorus reminds me a lot of hylt and that chorus has like 5-7 notes just recorded in two separate octaves although that was my only complaint but that complaint kind of reminded me of BLACKPINK and how the company doesn’t do enough for them and should make more of an effort to make them shine instead of having two members share the same pre chorus thats really only written for one of them I saw some ppl saying that it’s bc theres only four of them but look at DAY6 yes they have 5 members but 4 of them sing the fifth dowoon uses the drums and isn’t confident in his voice yet and their lines sound like they fit their voices and each line fits together no matter the tone of their voice. And the fact that they only got mini albums is another problem bc the writing process that’s used (check another yt video) the formula that can be heard throughout their songs IS ALL THE SAME and for the stuff saying how Boy didn’t give the yg sound in my opinion this feels like a doing of yg except evolved, I feel like the reason that they debuted this group was to show the next generation of yg bc while yes black pink and BIGBANG are two of their most successful groups and Block B being their dark horse of K-Pop then having Zico u can’t keep the same yg sound in every song bc then ppl grow out of that music like how so many blinks grow out of the music bc it never really changes u see other groups play with concepts not just boy groups even girl groups like Dreamcatcher and Loona, and recently G friend who have been slowly and strategically have been showing a new side through their music videos and I think Treasure is a attempt on the fourth generation and a attempt on separating them from the dark past and by evolving their yg sound is good for them think about Pokémon when a Pokémon evolves they usually get a wider move pool depending on the Pokémon allowing them to have more types of moves now let’s look at yg, their new sound sounds different but it’s still there it’s evolving or starting to and with a evolved sound you get so many new opportunities for different songs and with that surprise chorus background it makes you go oh heck! And if they change their concept a example being TXT yes their concept seems to always be cool mixed with cute and calm at times but every song sounds unique even being in the same album and their music videos are eye catching as fans try to figure out what’s going on adding engagement and by letting them interact with fans it strengthens that bond between artists and fans that is just one of the big things that K-Pop is known for. And if they can grow their concept make it their own then their fan base can become more solid keeping old fans while bringing in new they could go down a road like BLACKPINK where their fans eventually grow out of the music but new fans usually around teens (majority) come or BIGBANG who appealed to a more rounded audience most of them being early 20’s and some being even older than 20 being 50 and that means that ppl stay Big Bang fans bc their music appeals to a wider audience which really breaks the stereo types that only teenage girl listen to K-Pop and would be nice to see now that K-Pop is crashing their way into American markets, and a example of the evolved yg sound stretching into different concepts let’s look at the sm sound, it’s experimental and for nct you can feel that sound each song sounds different example is super m tiger inside (listening to it right now) the sound is different it sounds different and cool and the lines and dance fit the name and lyrics such as Taeyongs rap where he literally growls it adds character to it which makes songs stand out and in conclusion Treasures debut was great it showed a new side of Yg it surprised listeners with that chorus that didn’t sound like the yg sound yet still felt familiar which perhaps hylt was also a attempt at a new yg sound Bc they sound familiar not the same just like hmm. If that’s true then I give props to yg for experimenting on trying to change things and if that theory is true then that sound will become even more refined as time goes on and if yg becomes more lax with letting their idols interact it can unite fandoms I mean how many army fans became moa fans and how many onces became stays, midzys and days. And I mean a even better example is NCT by letting them interact with others who are not in their subunits unite the fans Bc they see them as a family and by doing that your widening that fandom and making it larger another attempt of that would be Super M combing fans from EXO NCT and Shinee. And besides as a fan there’s nothing more exciting than seeing your favorite idols interact with other idols I mean when I saw Straykids 3racha vlive with Twice and DAY6 it was amazing and hearing Seungmin fan boy for DAY6 was adorable and probably made stays who were not aware of the band want to check them out. In companies even if they are girls and the other groups are boys they can still be friends in my opinion that’s why ikon aren’t even allowed to talk to BLACKPINK bc yg is afraid they could start dating and ruin the careers but with a new group at the forefront hopefully being one of the leaders of the new generation that fear could loosen knowing that BLACKPINK is no longer their sole money bringing group as Ikon is amazing but not as known even tho their music is amazing. So in my opinion seeing the yg family like sm family jyp family fans love seeing it and it brings fans from those groups to see others. It’s not a competition when your from the same group which is why worth NCT the subunits don’t comeback at the same time because why make competition when your from the same group and company same with how Twice and Itzy don’t come back at the same time bc their both popular girl groups and JyP doesn’t want to make competition and let them shine. In my opinion same for Straykids and GOT7 sadly I feel like Straykids gets more love because their considered to be one of those groups to lead the fourth generation maybe not the most popular right now but way up there with those groups and GOT7 can’t be apart of that fourth generation leader because that title has so far been reserved for rookie groups or debuted during what people believed to be the beginning of the transition and I believe it’s time for that after K-Pop broke into the American market that was a huge turning point for the industry now it’s time for a turning point in the music. And if that’s true then of course JYP would want to fix their priorities right now become Itzy and Straykids at the front followed closely by Twice as that’s the named nations girl groups passed down form Girls generation or snsd then GOT7 and bc DAY6 self produces and don’t have any other competition within the company except for other bands outside the company they kinda are able to release freely as DAY6 is a vastly different group compared to let’s say GOT7 but equally talented. And Straykids release more Bc they have three producers so of course that process move faster and with the last two years of girl group debuts in my opinion the competition is as high. As it was when there was girls generation 2ne1 and Wonder girls. You have Loona who have had so much time and effort put into them each memeber getting a solo song, you have Dream catcher known for their unique concepts that are eye catching you have g-idle another self producing group which are becoming more popular you have izone. Then for Straykids it’s even more filled, ATEEZ names the fastest growing boy group, TXT with almost all the army transferring to them and amazingly talented like ATEEZ and Straykids every song apart of their album is equally amazing while u may like some better because of taste their all good. You got Treasure who can become a real power house if Yg play their cards right you have a lot of competition it’s simple. And with older groups that dominate the scene (BTS Seventeen GOT7 EXO starting SuperM (not naming girl groups bc the reason for the new groups to shine doesn’t apply to girl groups) are going to start military service at some point meaning those groups will most likely be on a long hiatus while EXO will still continue through the subunits and only having a few members go that opens up the floor especially at the award shows you saw how BTS was practically number 1 for almost every award that they could be nominated for even on the smaller ones where they even got black swan not even a title track on they dominated the boy group scene but with their hiatus it allows the groups to grow even more and gives the American scene that there’s more to K-Pop than just BTS I mean when they saw ATEEZ performing in public ppl thought they were BTS my grandma thought Nct127 was BTS .-. While I as a army will miss BTS I can see that they probably won’t loose any fans infact the comeback after the return form the military will probably be the most looked foward to thing of that year for K-Pop and beating out every other excitement for comeback since it would’ve been like two years.
Olivia Addison
Olivia Addison پیش 4 ماه
I'm not going to read all that😑
Alma XxX
Alma XxX پیش 4 ماه
They are teens so it would look wrong if it was something with the words women and man
Alma XxX
Alma XxX پیش 4 ماه
The people who doesn’t know the YG style likes the song, so I think that’s why people think it flopped, and they did say that they were gonna do different with treasure.
Adrian Johnson
Adrian Johnson پیش 4 ماه
Just commenting to say I DO remember boyfriend one of my favorite songs.
D- ReL
D- ReL پیش 4 ماه
I still yet to see a YG BOY BAND that can match Big Bang though they were the coolest
nutella no nut
nutella no nut پیش 4 ماه
The song isnt flop just below our expectation..
Pink Lamborghini
Pink Lamborghini پیش 4 ماه
When you said that Blackpink wouldn’t go that way, Ice Cream MV came to prove you wrong😹
axii پیش 4 ماه
okay so i only met them when they debut. i listened to their song it i fell inlove with it cuz it's a masterpiece for me yknow, their talents were just so great. i already know there was treasure before but i'm not paying much attention to it but yeah, i became a fan of them when i watched their mv and it became more when i watched ygtb. ngl, y'all only say that because they're from a big company who produces songs in a badass-like aura. y'all didn't saw that aura in treasure that's why you're complaining:/ i must say that i think, they have god tier talents yknow. if you're not alright with the concept, that's your opinion but i think that's the concept that suits their musical direction, personality and talents. i mean try listening to their vocalists and rappers. also, look at how they dance :/ yg also commented to them during ygtb that he thought it is not possible for yg to produce dances like that but by debuting them, he said he think yg can really do that.
S M پیش 4 ماه
this obese bitch is awful
Krashleash پیش 4 ماه
Y’all they are still flops this didn’t age well.......
anne sophie
anne sophie پیش 5 ماه
Like honestly? While boy isn't my favorite song in the world, I do think it's good. People just like to be mean. I'm glad they didn't go with a super dark or fierce concept, since the boys are still so young, it would feel out of place. Also- the whole 'it sounds like the same old yg trash' vs 'ew, they sound like they aren't even from yg' just kinda supports my stated opinion. People just enjoy being mean.
Yellow Mesh
Yellow Mesh پیش 5 ماه
Boy sucks. I was so excited but its awful.
Jonelle Solomon
Jonelle Solomon پیش 5 ماه
well i freakin love the song the music video and all of them ❤️😍
Just Dobby
Just Dobby پیش 5 ماه
Whoever that boy in the thumbnail. He could get it.
실버블렛 پیش 5 ماه
how tf is treasure trying to copy bts? i thought bts group was made based on bigbang lol
Zone X
Zone X پیش 5 ماه
BOY of treasure reminds me of NCT 127, Blackpink, BigBang and Seventeen type of sound/concepts
Zone X
Zone X پیش 5 ماه
Also make a content why JYP makes or pay more attention to Girl Groups!
Yellow Mesh
Yellow Mesh پیش 5 ماه
Jype has the flaw of not 'forcing' their acts to the gp, they are strategically catered to were they become organicaly sucesful without overbearing the general audience as they look for loyal fans rather than hype. With the growth of day6 and SKZ recognition from korea we have yet to see how they mánage them and the new growth. Jype understands ggs and bgs dont have the same perks, ggs get more attention but a much more fleeting fanbase down the line so they gotta keep them invested while bg have a more lasting fanbase that leads to better oportunities once outside the company.
orbitiny사샤 پیش 5 ماه
I‘m not just missing the old YG, I‘m kind of happy they try something new with releasing a new group but.. I miss the old 2nd gen vibes in general
bean پیش 5 ماه
Asahis Orange
Asahis Orange پیش 5 ماه
Ponze Joshua
Ponze Joshua پیش 5 ماه
forever young was iconic literally hahahhahahaha
Jennifer پیش 5 ماه
This song is amazing. I mean that’s just my opinion though
I'm trying besteu
I'm trying besteu پیش 5 ماه
Treasure's BOY mv is posted on their own youtube channel which is "TREASURE" 9.1m is alot for a new debuted group because youtube rules has changed..... and this one... Example: itzy posted their debut song mv on their company's youtube channel and of course it got alot of attention and views.... But YG posted TREASURE's "BOY" mv on their own youtube channel....not their company's youtube channel jsut like blackpink....and other YG groups... SO FOR ME 9.1M IS ALOT!! IRitem RULES HAS CHANGED SO ITS NOT THE SAME AS BEFORE...IT CHANGED SINCE SEPTEMBER 2019.....
nyummy's cute little addiction to woo
I just don't vibe with the music , its a no no for me :(
Raven Flor
Raven Flor پیش 3 ماه
we have different preferences but i like this song..
Yulie Nasution
Yulie Nasution پیش 5 ماه
Im an old YG stan... Ive followed YG since Se7en to bigbang to 2ne1 to winner to ikon to blackpink even i love akmu till now.. Se7en is my first crush of kpop btw. YG Sound?what do you mean? You mean all groups must have the same kind of sounds or like what? Its YG vibe. not sound bb,u heard se7en and bigbang?is it the same sound?or blackpink and 2ne1 sounds the same? Or do u wanna compare akmu to ikon?🤭🤭🤭 Even team a and b (read winner and ikon) didnt sounds the same. I think Treasure hv the same vibe as their seniors,its just..theyre still kids.. U know..the oldest is 1999 liner and the youngest is 2005 liner. The new YG wants to start out new fresh something.. That is treasure. If u following them u would know how different treasure kind of promotion with their seniors.. So please,just enjoy the new kind of YG boygroup. If u dont like it,leave it..if u like it support it. As easy as that.. I think music is personal taste,callin them flop isnt mature anyway🙂 Some of music right now even theyre makin world wide whatever dont hit my music spot anyway. That is called personal taste. (Sorry Grammar error,english is not my main languange)
skippyhippo پیش 5 ماه
The only thing I'm concerned about is how they are not doing too hot on the K charts. Like on Gaon and Melon they are no where to be seen. Hmm...which makes me wonder if they are more popular internationally
jimbun ALI
jimbun ALI پیش 5 ماه
Still remember people called bts and mamamoo a flop long time ago. And look at them now. 🤭🤭🤭.
Hana Mich
Hana Mich پیش 5 ماه
L-1485 EXOCb
L-1485 EXOCb پیش 5 ماه
"digital FLOPS"...Sis, the world ain't just South Korea. They're doing good everywhere in digitals except SK. But you know, let's just wait for their comeback and we'll see ;)
jungkookie army
jungkookie army پیش 5 ماه
I dont think TREASURE is flop. Well their have they own channel n already surpassed 1 million subscribers , n known as fastest rookie group got 1 million subscribers. They got 1 million subscribers bf theyre got debut THATS JUST WOW. N also their MV also uploaded by their own channel not their agency that just only had 1 millions subscribers. n got 1.1m or 1.2m likes in 24 hours. Its such new record as a rookie. Even their senior doesnt got that . I mean senior that not under YG . like gidle,everglow or etc. THEY IS ENOUGH TO SAY THEY WAS BOP.
Gloria Khumukcham
Gloria Khumukcham پیش 5 ماه
Ghala Alasseri
Ghala Alasseri پیش 5 ماه
The song is is yg but not the concept. I am so concerned for these boys... They are so talented and deserve success, but if yg is not going to change the “structure” of the song then people are gonna loose interest in them. In my opinion, the concept is different than the typical yg concept, but the structure is so fimiliar. Like verse1 pre-chorus then an empty chorus with onomatopoeias then verse 2 pre chorus chorus dance break... yk the typical yg structure. I loved the verses but the chorus wasn’t it
Reshie 323
Reshie 323 پیش 5 ماه
Some people really needs attention.. LOL FLOP???
Roman Roman
Roman Roman پیش 5 ماه
Everyone is like it wasnt a flop...... be real the song was a flop. The group isnt a flop but that song definately was.
Potre Aisha Malawani
Potre Aisha Malawani پیش 5 ماه
yg doesnt follow the trend, they make the trend. they are the trademark. this is how they made to stand out in a very competitive industry.
Peace Oclarit Y Rada
Peace Oclarit Y Rada پیش 5 ماه
Wow !!! You are right , that is why I stan them.
lanvia پیش 5 ماه
Allan L
Allan L پیش 5 ماه
it's not a flop. biggest album sales for a rookie group of 2020
multifandomyal پیش 5 ماه
the snyths and bass are yg. you can tell it at first listen.
Dooy پیش 5 ماه
I don’t really like the drop, but the verses are amazing imo
John Dinh
John Dinh پیش 5 ماه
They had a strong debut and the song itself showed off their strengths well but it was basic. A lot of the recent boy group debuts were of a similar vain like this, debuting with a teen crush sound as the members are young and can pull it off. And then their 1st comeback being a cute concept. I think what fans were expecting was something different from the current climate of kpop. The song itself may be different for YG but its not different in terms of kpop song. I would argue its fairly basic.
A Random Hot Trashcan
A Random Hot Trashcan پیش 5 ماه
I feel like kpop stans have too high expectations for everything.
Trixelle Cerda
Trixelle Cerda پیش 5 ماه
Flops or not, I will surely support these guys no matter what. Their debut might not be that successful, but knowing that these guys work hard to debut , to perform. Its all that matters. Teumes will support them no matter what. They have plenty of rooms to improve. And we will be there to witness those things. (sorry for my english)
FLY HIGH. HIGHER! پیش 5 ماه
YG’s New Boy Group TREASURE Tops iTunes Charts Across The Globe With Debut Single “BOY”
ttlee پیش 5 ماه
I know YG stans are upset that Treasure doesn’t have the typical YG sounds. However, why would YG add another hip hop boy group. They would be saturating the hiphop/kpop market, and two YG groups wouldn’t be able to promote as well at the same time. Big Bang and Ikon have more of that hip hop vibe, why add another? By trying this youthful fresh boy vibe they’re targeting a new market. Anyhow, congrats to their debut! I personally like this song, and the drop.
Blue harmony
Blue harmony پیش 5 ماه
I’m going to be honest I didn’t like “boy” but I understand it’s there debut song and they may come out with better music later
Tenzin Lhamo
Tenzin Lhamo پیش 5 ماه
why do they have to compare to there senoirs????????????? stupid
Treasure Jihoon's PILATES mat
Treasure are special and they have their own colour, same as Big Bang, 2ne1, winner, Ikon, akmu and blackpink. being a YG artist means to Stray away from norms and what is expected of you... Each and every yg artist does so and Treasure is no exception, they will grow into beautiful and original artists like Their label seniors. From what I've learned, during my 24 years of age, no matter what you do, you'll never be able to satisfy eveyone, Treasure would've gotten hate no matter what Their debut concept was so... I love how people are quick to judge their success rate after only one track ( which I find crème de la crème, very Yg too and I've been a YG stan since 2009 by the way). It would've been better if the fact that 3 of the members participating in writing the lyrics to both 'boy' and ' Come to me' and one of them making the track to Their debut teaser was highlighted... Let's not forget that Winner also were Said to be not YG when they debuted so Treasure getting hate and being called a flop is just ridiculous.
Gabbi Picar
Gabbi Picar پیش 5 ماه
Most of them were still teens so you can't blame them in using teen crush as a team. People these days are just insecure. 😂😂
Gabbi Picar
Gabbi Picar پیش 5 ماه
It's not a flop. I mean just watch the MV and look at their achievements. And don't forget how young our boys are. The team fits them. Don't expect them to release a song that doesn't fit the members.
Chuba Imsong
Chuba Imsong پیش 5 ماه
We just can't judge Treasure with their debut song .But in my opinion they were awesome !! They were the ones who made a record in V live with 1 billion hearts and 3 million views and also they are the 3rd most viewed debut group that also in their own channel and not the yg channel , cause mostly other kpop group debut their songs in their company 's channel and Treasure achieving such success being a rookie group is really woooh !! I don't care about what people think about their debut song , I strongly believe that they will be the next super star not only in K-Pop but also all around the world . Fighting !!!!
Ms. Anna Uyg
Ms. Anna Uyg پیش 5 ماه
To investigate - please watch everything
ionnik07 پیش 5 ماه
YG start to produce something that they dissed before, and that`s really sad and dissapointing, coming from the company of the "outcasts"', who always were different from the others.
Molly Gassor
Molly Gassor پیش 5 ماه
I do like how much comparing groups and songs there are in kpop. Like I understand if ur comparing songs in a positive way but just because one song has like more views then another doesn’t mean that the one with less views is bad. And every group is different, they can’t all be the same so I don’t know why people say “I wanted treasures debut song to be more like black pink or Big Bang” and stuff like that. Treasure is new and they are trying something new and I think it’s working out for them because most people in the comment section of the song say they love the song
Molly Gassor
Molly Gassor پیش 5 ماه
I don’t know why people think just because it doesn’t sound like yg then it’s a flop. Who cares if it doesn’t give a yg vibe, in my opinion it’s still an amazing song and I don’t even know anything about treasure but the song is making me want to Stan
EsterJamil Bunny
EsterJamil Bunny پیش 5 ماه
their vocals is not a joke.. don't judge.. who knows theyll become huge in 5 years..
Yangzee Phintso
Yangzee Phintso پیش 5 ماه
just cause you don’t like a song, doesn’t mean it’s a flop. they debuted literally less than a week ago, so there’s a thing called more potential
wooniek پیش 5 ماه
TREASURE doesn’t have a big Korean Fanbase, because of that lonnnng hiatus they’ve lost too many fans in Korea and the result is they don’t charts that HIGH. However when you compare them with others 2020 rookie groups their charts are really good
Michael Gamas
Michael Gamas پیش 5 ماه
success in youtube is for international audience only. As a Korean band, they must also be in some form of success on their home territory.
eli_dashaloverr پیش 5 ماه
What dose you mean ? Flop, don't compare them , if they are flop but ,in my heart they are like diamond to me 😂
Fahmi_duh !
Fahmi_duh ! پیش 5 ماه
Ik BOY is a bop that i listen for hours but..do anyone have thoughts like debuting with Going Crazy would have been better? The bold moves and risks are what i live for yet as it's kpop,"they" are somewhat stuck to usual genres i feel which might have favoured Going Crazy..? Im not criticising ANY song,instead BOTH ARE MY JAM! It's just simply...your thought and im interested to know:/
Peace Oclarit Y Rada
Peace Oclarit Y Rada پیش 5 ماه
Going Crazy is a signal song of YGTB. And I don't think Yedam is the only shine. Btw Jihoon is the one who catched their attention. Also Jeongwoo. And also Junkyu. And also Asahi. And also Haruto. In short all of them catch the attention. So Yedam and his friends is Impossible😂 I think Jihoon have more articles than Yedam in Naver.
Non G
Non G پیش 5 ماه
Hi, in terms of catching the Korean public’s attention yes I do feel like going crazy would have better, and would have done better in Korean charts. I feel like it could easily be incorporated in variety shows if that makes sense. But I feel like if they did people would have labeled it as “Yedam and friends” for those who aren’t familiar with Treasure before hand as his already known by Knetz and as he got more lines in that song.
Don’tmindme پیش 5 ماه
Rid yourself of the 4 C’s: COMPARE, COMPETE, CRITICIZE, and COMPLAIN, They are the thieves of Joy and Happiness - Howie Fields 😉
Jin Woo
Jin Woo پیش 5 ماه
The fact that some groups don’t get even a million views within a year is not because their songs are bad. It’s because they are from small companies and not many people know about them. This is why groups from big companies like YG have a huge fan base even before debuting. Of course their MVs are going to get a lot of views because no one knows if the song is good or not before they watch / listen to it.
Nithsirla پیش 5 ماه
It didn't flop. It's a meh as in "its not that bad but its also not good" kind of meh. And yes, i do remember Boyfriend's "Boyfriend"
darna j
darna j پیش 5 ماه
People forgot that Treasure released their concept teaser. It says they're gonna show something different.
Wapa Kels
Wapa Kels پیش 5 ماه
It's doesn't really matter. Whatever they do at the end there will always be complain. An idol can't please everybody. If you like them OK and if you don't like them it's OK nobody is forcing you. Only time will tell what will happened to them if they will gonna flop or be successful we can't say. Only time will tell.
Severhina Samoa
Severhina Samoa پیش 5 ماه
I personally think it's not a flop given that Yg targets international success. Plus The song isn't the bad it has the flow and moves that fits the members well.
YGNISM پیش 5 ماه
Girl they are 4th gen boy group, theyre debut song definitely sounds like yg 😡
YGNISM پیش 5 ماه
Treasure is better that txt
k پیش 5 ماه
okay but look at bts. theur debut wasnt very successful either and look at them now. you might not like the song and that is okay but they are so talented and have so much potential.
Asteria Selene
Asteria Selene پیش 5 ماه
Been a YG Stan since Golden Era of Kpop, and I can say that BOY has the YG vibe. Its BOP.
Naishmai_eng_honors_0010 پیش 5 ماه
This sing is sooooooo NOT A FLOP!!!
I honestly really liked the song. The vocals were amazing. I love the dance. And I honestly think it has that YG feeling to it at the end of the song there was a little part where all the members sing together and it's kind of like a party and YG tends to do that a lot. (Ex. Boombayah by BlackPink, Bang bang bang by Big bang, Bling by iKon, Can't nobody by 2ne1 and probably many more). Of course they could've been better (since we waited a year for their debut). Another thing is of course they would do a sort of boyish concept considering the members are really young, some of the members are literally only 1-2 year older than me (i'm 14). They won't do a very mature and sexy concept. In conclusion, stan treasure and be happy that they finally debuted and appreciate their talent and hardwork.
Joaquin Ramirez
Joaquin Ramirez پیش 5 ماه
Y'all if u're not a fan or you're not going to stan that group, keep out of their own damn business! Like, some of y'all are just wasting your time spreading hate, why don't just use that time to stream u're faves' mvs, right? At least, if you're going to say something, SAY SOMETHING DAMN POSITIVE! The world's a mess right now as it is, and y'all are just contributing to that mess. Some of these dumb bitches are just really getting on my nerve smh 🤦‍♀️
Gianna Beatrice Ferrer
Gianna Beatrice Ferrer پیش 5 ماه
The one I learned about Kpop is never judge a group by their debut because you'll never know the future. And BOY was actually a very YG song, the song slaps hard and I honestly love it so much.
ana luiza
ana luiza پیش 5 ماه
yg is going into the basic side of kpop with this group
ana luiza
ana luiza پیش 5 ماه
the album sales are a joke, honestly the albuns were extremely cheap lmao, compared to other yg groups they did flop
Why Itzy's "Not Shy" is Familiar